We earn commissions from brands listed on this site, which influences how listings are presented.

Is Pet Insurance Worth It?

As pet parents face increasingly expensive medical bills for their four-legged family members, many turn to pet insurance as a potential solution.

This site is a free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to our visitors. We accept advertising compensation from companies that appear on the site, which may impact the location and order in which brands (and/or their products) are presented, and may also impact the score that is assigned to it. Company listings on this page DO NOT imply endorsement. We do not feature all providers on the market. Except as expressly set forth in our Terms of Use, all representations and warranties regarding the information presented on this page are disclaimed. The information, including pricing, which appears on this site is subject to change at any time

A woman sitting with her pet and wondering if pet insurance is worth it.
David Kindness Bio
David Kindness
Dec. 08, 20244 min read
Unexpected injury or illness can quickly lead to hefty vet bills, causing financial strain on many pet owners.

This is where our best pet insurance providers come into play, offering financial protection for your furry friend’s health needs.

But is pet insurance worth it? The answer isn’t always a simple yes or no. It depends on your individual circumstances and your pet’s needs. This article will explore the factors you should consider when deciding if pet insurance is right for you.

Key Insights

  • Pet insurance can help cover veterinary expenses for accidents, illnesses, surgeries, and medications.
  • While vaccines are not typically covered by insurance, some pet insurance providers offer pet wellness plans as an add-on to cover routine care and vaccinations.
  • Pet insurance isn't always a one-size-fits-all solution. However, many pet owners can benefit from reduced costs.
  • There are alternative options to pet insurance, such as setting up a pet savings account.

BestMoney Logo



When Is Pet Insurance Worth It?

Emergency Medical Costs

It's an unfortunate reality that unexpected vet bills can be a real financial burden. Imagine adopting a precious puppy and then having them diagnosed with a serious illness like cancer not long after.

The cost of treatment could easily reach tens of thousands of dollars. With pet insurance, however, you wouldn't have to make the heartbreaking decision to sacrifice your pet's well-being due to financial limitations.

Breed-Specific Health Issues

Pet insurance can also be a lifesaver for breeds prone to certain health conditions, such as hip dysplasia in German Shepherds or brachycephalic syndrome in pugs. Early diagnosis and treatment can significantly improve a pet's quality of life, but these interventions can be expensive.

Long-Term Security

Pet insurance allows you to make medical decisions based on your pet's well-being rather than financial constraints. You can confidently approve recommended treatments, from routine checkups to urgent procedures. This proactive approach to healthcare helps identify and address issues early—potentially saving both money and heartache down the road.




How Much Does Pet Insurance Cost?

Pet insurance costs an average of $612 per year for dogs and $324 for cats, but these figures are just a starting point.

Several factors can impact the cost of your pet insurance policy, including the species of your pet, breed, age, health conditions commonly associated with your pet’s breed, and any unexpected medical conditions that come up during your pet’s life. Below, we’ll explore the specific factors that affect pet insurance costs.




Factors Affecting Pet Insurance Costs

  • Pet type: Your pet's species significantly influences insurance costs, with dogs typically costing more than cats. Exotic pet insurance for birds, reptiles, and small mammals often needs specialized care, which can affect premium rates.
  • Breed considerations: Different breeds face varying health risks. For example, large dog breeds may be prone to hip dysplasia, while short-nosed breeds often develop respiratory issues. Insurance companies adjust premiums based on these breed-specific issues.
  • Age and life stage: Due to higher health risks, premium costs typically increase with your pet's age. Many insurers have age limits for new policies, and coverage options may become more limited for senior pets.
  • Health history: Most insurers don't cover pre-existing conditions, but some may cover conditions that have been cured and haven't recurred for a specific period.
  • Financial planning: Consider your deductible options and reimbursement levels. A higher deductible typically means lower monthly premiums, while a lower deductible means higher premiums but less out-of-pocket expense when you file a claim.
  • Coverage benefits: Quality pet insurance can cover emergencies, preventive care, prescription medications, and specialist visits. Some policies even include coverage for alternative therapies or behavioral treatments, providing comprehensive health support for your pet.




What Does Pet Insurance Cover vs. Not Cover

Pet insurance covers some of the most expensive medical aspects of pet ownership, but standard pet insurance policies don't cover everything. Pet wellness plans are designed to fill in these gaps in coverage.

Coverage TypeWhat's IncludedWhat's Not Included
Standard pet insuranceVet visits (with copay), surgeries, hospitalizations, diagnostics, and prescriptions and medicationsPre-existing conditions, routine care, vaccines, spaying and neutering, behavioral problems, grooming, and cosmetic procedures
Pet wellness plansVaccinations, spaying and neutering, dental cleanings (may require add-on coverage)Vet visits, emergency care, surgeries, diagnostics, prescriptions/medications

Note: Before purchasing a policy, be sure to review key details like waiting periods, annual limits, and coverage exclusions to avoid surprises when you need to file a claim.




Should You Get Pet Insurance?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to whether pet insurance will be worth it for you. Here are some questions you should ask when considering signing up for pet insurance:

  • What breed is your pet? Some pet breeds are more predisposed to health issues than others. If your pet’s breed is likely to suffer from a chronic health issue or an unexpected health emergency like cancer or diabetes, you may want pet insurance to prepare for this eventuality.

  • Can you comfortably afford unexpected veterinary bills? Depending on the severity of your pet’s medical issues, unexpected bills can reach thousands or even tens of thousands of dollars. If these potential expenses are too great, pet insurance may be worth considering.

  • Is your pet young and healthy, or are they older and losing health? Younger, healthier pets are less likely to require pet insurance, while older pets or those with chronic health conditions are more likely to need it.

  • How important is your peace of mind? For some pet owners, the peace of mind offered by pet insurance is well worth the monthly premiums. For others, the stress is manageable and they may not prioritize the expense of pet insurance.



Alternative Options to Pet Insurance

While pet insurance is a popular choice for many pet owners, it’s not the only way to manage your pet’s health care costs. Here are some helpful alternatives to traditional pet insurance that may be worth considering:

  • Pet savings account: Set aside money regularly for future vet bills in a separate bank account.

  • Emergency fund: Allocate a portion of your regular emergency fund for pet expenses.

  • Payment plans: Work with your vet to create payment plans to help make larger bills more manageable.

  • Preventative care: Regular check-ups, vaccinations, and healthy lifestyle choices can help prevent costly illnesses.

Whether you choose one of these alternatives or decide to get insurance, being proactive about your pet's healthcare costs is essential. If you do opt for insurance coverage, be sure to check out our tips for reducing pet insurance costs to help keep your premiums affordable while maintaining quality coverage for your furry friend.

David Kindness Bio
Written byDavid Kindness

David, a CPA with a Bachelor's in Accounting, is based in San Diego and specializes in taxation, accounting, and finance. He has worked as a tax expert and Senior Accountant with high-net-worth clients and businesses. David has contributed to Investopedia, The Balance, Techopedia, and BestMoney.com.

View Rates